"When I give, I give myself." -- Walt Whitman
Posted on Friday, January 12, 2007 6:59 PM
By Randall S. Newton
Editor-in-Chief

Malcolm Davies, Ph.D., the CAD industry executive with the longest resume in the business, has resigned as CEO of Gehry Technologies. He will be the new CEO of Michelle Kaufmann Designs (MKD) of Oakland, California, an architecture firm that is moving into prefab sustainable design/build.

There is no word from Gehry Technologies at this time regarding a successor for Davies. The company was founded as a spin-off of leading architecture firm Gehry Partners, which has used mechanical CAD product CATIA from Dassault Systèmes to help design a number of world-class signature architecture projects. Under Gehry Technologies the product became Digital Project. It has sold in small quantities (numbers have never been released) to a few large architecture and construction firms. Last month Skidmore, Owings & Merrill (SOM), one of America's largest architecture firms, announced it would buy 100 copies of Digital Project, GT's largest sale to date. We expect an announcement in the near future about GT's next moves.

Davies' new employer was named to the Inc. Magazine's "Green 50" List in November 2006. As the magazine noted:
Michelle Kaufmann Designs, based in Oakland, California, has helped to usher in the next generation of prefabricated housing: ecologically astute, energy-efficient, factory-built homes with modernist verve (and with approachable prices; the total cost of a home tops out at about $250 a square foot). Because they're built indoors after meticulous planning, construction waste is essentially eliminated. And the houses are beautiful, mixing elements such as geothermal heating and cooling systems with modern touches such as clerestory windows, Cor-Ten steel siding, and gliding glass doors. Her breakthrough design, the Glidehouse, is on display at the National Building Museum in Washington, D.C.
Davies has held executive positions in the CAD industry at GE/Calma, Autodesk, Cadkey, Nemetschek, Rebis, Bentley, and Gehry Technologies. He was senior vice president at Autodesk during the time of its early fast growth, and was considered by most observers to be the informal co-CEO with Al Green. He was denied the opportunity to be CEO when theAutodesk board decided to go outside the company to replace the retiring Green in 1989, choosing Carol Bartz, at the time a sales executive at Sun Microsystems.

Davies' career moves have led me to think of him as the CAD industry's patron saint of hopeless causes. He attempted to turn Cadkey (now Kubotek) into a retail powerhouse, then tried to introduce the German architecture program ALLPLAN into North America. Both times, I believe, the goal was not achieved because of ownership's unwillingness to completely implement Davies' plans. That doesn't seem to be the case at GT with Digital Practice, which suffers not from lack of ownership interest but from being based on the most expensive and most difficult to use CAD program on the market.


Feedback

# re: Malcolm Davies Leaves Gehry Technologies for Sustainable Design/Build Innovator

1/16/2007 2:35 PM by Barry Dyson
>Davies' career moves have led me to think of him as the CAD industry's patron saint of hopeless causes. He attempted to turn Cadkey (now Kubotek) into a retail powerhouse, then tried to introduce the German architecture program ALLPLAN into North America. Both times, I believe, the goal was not achieved because of ownership's unwillingness to completely implement Davies' plans<

You have got to be KIDDING!

I believe it was Davies himself who was the hopeless cause!
Davies was one of the owners.
And it was HE who dropped the ball. No-one else.

As an editor, (?), you would be well advised to make better educated and less derogatory statements regarding CAD Products like KeyCreator (Cadkey), than was done in this article.

Barry Dyson
Managing Director
STS Pty Ltd
Australian KeyCreator (Cadkey) Distributor for past 18 years.

# re: Malcolm Davies Leaves Gehry Technologies for Sustainable Design/Build Innovator

1/16/2007 3:15 PM by Barry Dyson
My apologies to the editor and to Malcom Davies regarding my above comments about Malcolm Davies.
I was mistaken regarding Malcolm Davies' previous position at Cadkey (now KeyCreator).
Malcolm was an appointed CEO and not an owner.
It was not Malcolm Davies who was the previous owner who "dropped the ball".
And it could well have been that his goal was not achieved "because of ownership's unwillingness to completely implement Davies' plans" as was stated in the article.

However, my comments regarding the editor being less derogatory about high calibre CAD products like KeyCreator (Cadkey) still stand.

Barry Dyson.

# re: Malcolm Davies Leaves Gehry Technologies for Sustainable Design/Build Innovator

2/2/2007 2:24 PM by David Ruiz
Randall:

I know nothing about Digital Project, but the following comment caught my attention:

"That doesn't seem to be the case at GT with Digital Practice (Project), which suffers not from lack of ownership interest but from being based on the most expensive and most difficult to use CAD program on the market."

Does Gehry Technologies have a key competitor whose product rivals theirs in scope and capability?

DR
deruiz@earthlink.net

# re: Malcolm Davies Leaves Gehry Technologies for Sustainable Design/Build Innovator

2/10/2007 8:03 AM by CJB
Digital Project is without question the most expensive and difficult to learn 3D/4D cad software available on the market. They do not really have any competition as they are not really IN competition, if you get my meaning. They have sold not more than 350 seats world wide and their largest customer by far is Gehry Partners. It is also interesting to note that no one at Gehry Technologies was involved on a day to day basis in any of the successful projects of the 90's and very early aughts, such as Guggenhiem Bilbao, Walt Disney Concert Hall, etc. That work was done largely with the help of consultants C3 Virtual Architecture (now C3 Virtual Build) using CATIA V4 software NOT V5 or Digital Project, which is a research and development software in truth.

Essentially what Frank Gehry did was to throw out 12 years of successful process development, at the request of Jim Glymph (fired by Frank over a year ago) and Dennis Shelden, and launch a foray in to software development with software that was never tested or proven to be successful in any way in AEC. Malcolm Davies came in after all of that and was in no way responsible for the lack of success at GT. His hands were tied before he got there. He moves on to a much better situation I assure you.

CATIA V4/V5 remain the cad product with the most thorough throughput of any BIM software on the market, able to take a project from schematics to fabrication to construction, but the cost and learning curve make it essential to have experienced help when trying to implement new technology and process. REVIT and Archicad and the rest are, while improvements to AEC process, simply enhancements of the 2D paradigm.

# re: Malcolm Davies Leaves Gehry Technologies for Sustainable Design/Build Innovator

2/10/2007 3:54 PM by Rick Smith
The truth be told, the Gehry Technologies/Digital Project “hopeless cause” cannot be placed at the feet of Malcolm Davis. It’s a complicated story that is still unraveling.

Frank Gehry’s office was successful in implementing technology on his complex architecture and was the forerunner to the concept of BIM, because of a company called C3 Virtual Architecture. C3VA brought the process to his office in 1992 and performed the computer work until 2002 using CATIA Versions 3 and 4.

When Frank’s office began to find great success and notoriety from the use of this technology two individuals namely Jim Glymph (who was later fired) and Dennis Shelden (both of which who had no experience with the technology) convinced Frank that they could make millions in selling the software. C3VA warned them of such a venture reminding them they were just then beginning to accept the use of 3D modeling let alone to start writing, marketing and supporting computer software. They are an architectural design firm and had become very successful at that. They should build on those strengths and not become a software developer.

After the completion of the Walt Disney Concert Hall, C3VA was asked to leave the office and Gehry Technologies (GT) was formed by these two individuals who then made claim to the previous decade’s success stories as their own. There is a gross misrepresentation to the architectural community by GT that they and their product, Digital Project was the program that performed all the previous work on Frank’s buildings.

The program used on all of those successful projects was CATIA Version 3 and 4. It works very much in concept like Rhino which many architects are familiar with, but on steroids. Digital Project, which is a small subset of CATIA V5 is completely different in so many ways from the previous versions of CATIA. It has become highly specific to aerospace and automobile design/manufacturing. It is very hard to learn and was never adapted properly or tested as a viable product for the AEC industry before GT began marketing it. In a sense they expected the AEC industry to rely on GT’s marketing and PR that Digital Project was used on the past successes and then have customers implement, test, debug and develop the use of the product for them.

Malcolm knew none of this previous history so he can not be blamed for its lack of its success.

Bottom line, C3VA didn’t just introduce a computer program to Frank Gehry’s office, we introduced and managed a thorough process that captured his designs and conveyed them through to construction for a decade. Its not as much about what program you use as to how you use it in a thorough process.
Comments on this post are closed